DOUGIE: I'd written Eleanor a short list of things training ought to explain better. ELEANOR: It had a contents page. DOUGIE: There's thirty years in that list. ELEANOR: I suggested we work through it together. He'd tell me where an explanation fell apart in the bay. DOUGIE: She'd tell me where I'd been replacing the explanation with a hand gesture. ELEANOR: We were supposed to do one afternoon. DOUGIE: Then we got on rather well. Don't tell her. ELEANOR: I'm standing here. DOUGIE: Saves me emailing you. DOUGIE: The owner says not to worry about the front fog lamps. They have never worked during his ownership. ELEANOR: A full service history of not working. DOUGIE: His next argument is that they are optional. Which is a useful word, provided we establish optional for what. ELEANOR: Buying the car? Using them today? Having their operation inspected? Those are different questions. DOUGIE: Here's the published example for this year's training. A car first used in twenty sixteen. Front and rear fog lamps fitted. Front fog lamps inoperative. ELEANOR: The published answer is pass. For that stated front-fog problem. It is not a prediction about every other item on the car. DOUGIE: Because the manual says to inspect front fog lamps fitted to vehicles first used on or after the first of March twenty eighteen. ELEANOR: Which twenty sixteen was not. However confidently the owner has arranged his number plates. DOUGIE: We establish first use, rather than treating every fitted lamp as the same inspection item. Then we apply the relevant requirements. ELEANOR: Now change our example. A car first used in twenty nineteen, with front fog lamps in scope and connected, but inoperative. DOUGIE: That takes us to the defect table. An inoperative front fog lamp is a major defect. We have changed a relevant fact, so the decision changes. ELEANOR: Not because the newer owner argued less convincingly. DOUGIE: He hasn't started yet. He's still finding the advertisement that says premium lighting package. ELEANOR: Premium describes the invoice. It does not describe the test result. DOUGIE: There's another condition worth keeping. Front fog lamps that aren't wired up and have no corresponding switch aren't required to work. If we aren't sure they're connected, we give the benefit of the doubt. ELEANOR: That is the manual's specific instruction. It is not permission to call every dark lamp disconnected. DOUGIE: And rear fog lamps have their own requirements. For vehicles first used on or after the first of April nineteen eighty, the required rear fog lamp is at the centre or offside, subject to the listed exemptions. ELEANOR: So our twenty-sixteen example doesn't excuse an obligatory rear fog lamp that fails to work. DOUGIE: Here's what we do. Identify the lamp. Establish the vehicle's first-use date. Check the scope and any applicable exception. Then use the correct defect, if there is one. ELEANOR: The sequence matters. Scope first, defect second. The owner's explanation can go third. DOUGIE: We might need another appointment for that. ELEANOR: Next time, two headlamp images. Both look tidy. Only one is being judged against the correct diagram.