ELEANOR: The owner has filmed a lamp switching off. DOUGIE: Ten seconds of video, then four minutes explaining the ten seconds. ELEANOR: He has selected director's commentary. DOUGIE: It is a daytime running lamp. It goes out when the indicator on that side operates. Which can be permitted behaviour, not an intermittent fault. ELEANOR: The manual expressly permits a daytime running lamp to switch off when the same-side indicator operates. DOUGIE: Establish which function we're watching first. Modern lamp units do several jobs. We can't judge one function as though it were another. ELEANOR: Like a person who has been given reception, invoicing and stock control, then criticised for leaving the desk. DOUGIE: That person would like to know when you're coming back from your lamp inspection. ELEANOR: As soon as the lamp has fewer responsibilities than I do. DOUGIE: There is an inspection-scope point as well. Daytime running lamps are inspected when fitted as original equipment to M one vehicles first used on or after the first of March twenty eighteen. ELEANOR: Keep that scope with the rule. A position lamp is not simply a daytime running lamp with less enthusiasm. DOUGIE: For position lamps combined with indicators, the position lamp may or may not switch off while the corresponding indicator flashes. ELEANOR: And for the combined arrangement described in the indicator instructions on vehicles first used on or after the first of September nineteen sixty-five, the indicator must flash amber only. No white or red light in that flash. DOUGIE: So allowed switching behaviour doesn't excuse an incorrect indicator colour. We assess each function under the relevant requirements. ELEANOR: There's a rear-lamp example too. Some LED rear lamps extinguish a proportion of the stop-lamp LEDs when the rear fog lamp is illuminated. DOUGIE: The manual says that behaviour is not a defect. We don't count those deliberately extinguished parts as failed light sources just because we caught them in that operating combination. ELEANOR: Nor should we turn that example into a general exemption for every dark part of a stop lamp. DOUGIE: Operate the functions and check what is actually happening. Is this the specified behaviour, a fault, or something we haven't identified correctly yet? ELEANOR: Sequential indicators are another familiar example. Their sequential operation is not itself a reason to fail. DOUGIE: That doesn't mean they escape the other applicable indicator requirements. Impressive choreography is not an inspection category. ELEANOR: Mine is normally described as moving round the owner to reach the switch. DOUGIE: Here's what we do. Identify the functions, establish their inspection scope, operate them in the relevant combinations and apply the specific instructions. Don't diagnose a multifunction unit from a single frozen frame. ELEANOR: Ask the learner activity to show the sequence, with a written description as well as pictures. It is the change between states that matters. DOUGIE: And if the owner offers the extended version? ELEANOR: We already have the relevant footage.