DOUGIE: The dashboard says the pads are worn. The owner says they're fine. At least one of them has had a look. ELEANOR: The dashboard has the advantage of arriving with the car. DOUGIE: Our example is a twenty-seventeen class four M one car. Wear indicator illuminated. We can't see the inner front pads. The other pads are satisfactory. ELEANOR: That's the situation in the published group B sample question. Its answer is pass and advise. DOUGIE: Not remove the front wheels. Not invent a thickness for the pads we can't see. ELEANOR: And not fail it simply because the brake wear indicator is lit. Section one point one point thirteen says that isn't a reason for failure. DOUGIE: Which doesn't mean we ignore the brakes. We inspect what the test permits us to inspect. The MOT is carried out without dismantling. ELEANOR: A warning gives us information. It doesn't supply a photograph of an inaccessible pad. DOUGIE: The owner has supplied a photograph. Of the car on his drive. ELEANOR: Lovely. The brake pads will want their own photographer. DOUGIE: Now change the facts. We can see a pad, and it's worn down to its wear indicator. That's a major defect. ELEANOR: Below one point five millimetres is dangerous. Those are findings about the pad, rather than a dashboard message. DOUGIE: We keep those distinctions separate. Otherwise a light can fail a sound component, while a bad component gets waved through because the light's off. ELEANOR: The component does not become satisfactory by declining to make an announcement. DOUGIE: Same care with a disc. The manual says it must be significantly worn before we reject it. Below the manufacturer's recommended limit isn't a reason in itself. ELEANOR: But a significantly and obviously worn disc or drum is a major defect. An insecure or fractured one, or one otherwise likely to fail, is dangerous. DOUGIE: We're not setting up a contest between our eyes and a manufacturer's service advice. We're applying the MOT criteria to what we actually find. ELEANOR: A service recommendation and an MOT rejection criterion can be different things. Explain that without making either sound optional. DOUGIE: Here's what we do. Carry out the permitted inspection. Record the observed defect against the right criterion. Make the limitation and advice clear where the published example calls for it. ELEANOR: And keep the example's conditions. We haven't said every car with a wear warning passes, regardless of anything else wrong with it. DOUGIE: The lamp tells a story. The owner tells a story. We still have to inspect the car. ELEANOR: The photograph can stay in reception.