DOUGIE: I've reviewed my quality-control system. Excellent tester. Tremendous experience. Very pleased with him. ELEANOR: Who checked his work? DOUGIE: That is where the review becomes less independent. ELEANOR: You've appointed yourself a panel. DOUGIE: Being the owner doesn't make my tests exempt. Neither does being the only tester here. ELEANOR: The guidance says every tester's tests should be checked by someone else. So a sole tester needs a workable arrangement involving another person. DOUGIE: An experienced tester carrying out assurance checks. A third party. Or partner with another centre. The guidance offers those options, alongside a rota where there are several testers. ELEANOR: The useful word is "workable". A plan relying on someone you've been meaning to telephone is still an unanswered telephone call. DOUGIE: Check at least one test from each tester every two months. Then decide whether more frequent checking is needed. ELEANOR: Consider experience, how many tests they do and any issues with testing standards. The minimum isn't a reason to ignore a developing problem. DOUGIE: And the check needs to cover the work. The checker can closely observe all parts of the test, or re-examine the vehicle using the correct standards. ELEANOR: Waving through the bay door is an excellent greeting. It isn't either of those. DOUGIE: Afterward, discuss differences in results or observations. Agree any corrections. The tester can then enter the test result on the MOT testing service. ELEANOR: That conversation is where a lot of the value sits. "Fine" is a conclusion. It doesn't tell you what was checked or how a disagreement was resolved. DOUGIE: Record the result, corrections, agreed actions and any training needs. If a particular procedure needs work, make that the next useful action. ELEANOR: Not "improve standards" written in capital letters. The larger handwriting rarely repairs the smaller process. DOUGIE: And review the assurance process itself. Does it find things? Do actions actually happen? Are you checking every tester? ELEANOR: The guidance makes a sensible observation. If the process never finds anything wrong, it may not be working effectively. DOUGIE: That doesn't mean manufacture a fault to make the paperwork look lively. It means question whether the checks are doing the job. ELEANOR: Particularly when all the reports consist of the same remarkably brief word. DOUGIE: Right. Here's what we do. Name the checker. Arrange the checks. Cover the whole test or re-examine properly. Discuss, correct, record and follow up. ELEANOR: Including the owner who tests. DOUGIE: I'll invite him to the meeting. ELEANOR: Bring another chair. For someone else.