DOUGIE: The customer says the knocking has stopped, so the car must have improved. ELEANOR: That would be a refreshingly economical repair. DOUGIE: The anti-roll bar link has fractured. The two pieces have stopped arguing with each other. ELEANOR: So the noise stopped because the connection stopped. We assess the component, not the success of its silence. DOUGIE: Start with the whole arrangement. Bar, links, joints, bushes, brackets and attachments. A loose-looking rubber bush and a fractured link aren't the same finding. ELEANOR: The manual's suspension-component table lists a fractured component, or one likely to fail, as dangerous. We don't rename a fracture wear to get a more comfortable category. DOUGIE: Nor is it an advisory simply because the customer hasn't noticed a handling problem. The defect wording is what we apply. ELEANOR: A component that is excessively damaged or corroded, without meeting that fractured or likely-to-fail description, is listed as major. DOUGIE: Check attachment as well. Insecure attachment to the chassis or axle is major. Missing, likely to become detached, or directional stability impaired is the dangerous wording in that part of the table. ELEANOR: Those conditions matter. Major and dangerous aren't small and large handwriting. DOUGIE: Jointed links need their joint checks. Excessive wear in a suspension joint is major. Likely detachment is dangerous. ELEANOR: And a protective cover has its own distinction. Severely deteriorated is minor; missing or no longer preventing dirt ingress is major. DOUGIE: Then the rubber bushes. Some are designed to move. For rubber or synthetic bushes, the manual says only reject when we can see serious deterioration of the bonding or flexible material. ELEANOR: We aren't trying to turn every flexible connection into a rigid one. The manufacturer has already had a meeting about that. DOUGIE: What matters is the actual condition, under the right examination. Follow the suspension guidance, and inspect the mountings and brackets rather than stopping at the first shiny replacement part. ELEANOR: Especially when the customer's photograph shows only that part. DOUGIE: He's taken it from an angle that makes the rest of the car look optional. ELEANOR: Very useful for selling it. Less useful for examining it. DOUGIE: Here's what we do. Identify the failed item. Is it a fractured component, an insecure attachment, an excessively worn joint, or a deteriorated protective cover? Assess the relevant finding and category. ELEANOR: Then explain the reason in words the presenter can follow. A broken connection is still broken when it is quiet. DOUGIE: He says it's a pity. It's the quietest it's been in years. ELEANOR: The improvement was entirely acoustic.