ELEANOR: The customer has helpfully identified the brake pipe. It's the one he says we shouldn't look at. DOUGIE: He's painted an arrow on it. ELEANOR: Discretion was never going to survive the arrow. DOUGIE: There is dirt on the pipe. Before we decide it's corrosion, we need to see what we're assessing. ELEANOR: The manual permits light scraping with a specialist brake pipe corrosion tool or the corrosion tool's spade end. Take care not to damage the protective coating. DOUGIE: Lightly. We aren't restoring an iron gate. If our inspection removes the coating, we've added our own problem. ELEANOR: Section one point one point eleven gives the criterion for deterioration reducing the wall thickness by a third. It acknowledges that determining that isn't easy. DOUGIE: And where we're unsure whether it's sufficiently deteriorated to justify rejection, we give the benefit of the doubt. That's in the guidance, not a discount for a persuasive owner. ELEANOR: It's also not permission to overlook an obvious defect. A pipe at imminent risk of failure or fracture is dangerous. DOUGIE: A damaged or excessively corroded pipe is major. Assess the actual condition and use the matching defect. ELEANOR: At least the arrow tells us where his confidence runs out. DOUGIE: Then we move to the flexible hose, and the criteria change. For excessive damage or chafing, the manual says the damage must be severe enough to expose reinforcement. ELEANOR: Don't transplant that sentence onto every hose defect. A bulge under pressure is its own major defect. Leakage and likely failure have their own criteria too. DOUGIE: So a hose doesn't need to display its reinforcement before every possible defect can apply. ELEANOR: Correct. Slight damage, chafing or twisting is listed as minor. The excessive conditions are major. A damaged hose likely to fail is dangerous. DOUGIE: Which is why we describe what we found before choosing the wording. We don't choose the dramatic wording and then go looking for something to match it. ELEANOR: I tried that with the stationery order. We now own a heavy-duty stapler and nothing heavy-duty to staple. DOUGIE: You've stapled the delivery note to the box. ELEANOR: A controlled trial. DOUGIE: One more point. A leaking hydraulic brake pipe or connection is dangerous. The same section lists an air-system leak as major. We identify the system, not just the word leak. ELEANOR: Here's what we do. Expose the condition carefully where permitted. Distinguish pipe from hose and identify the system. Apply the criterion for the finding we actually have. DOUGIE: And if somebody has painted an arrow, we still inspect the rest of it.