DOUGIE: The parking brake holds. The cable has broken strands. The owner says we should judge it by results. ELEANOR: I would prefer it to arrive with all its original strands. DOUGIE: He's pulled the lever three times to demonstrate. As though the fourth demonstration repairs the cable. ELEANOR: A persuasive performance. From the owner. DOUGIE: We inspect the mechanism as well as testing what the brakes achieve. A satisfactory hold doesn't erase a component defect. ELEANOR: Section one point one point fifteen covers the cables, rods, levers and linkages. A damaged or knotted cable is a major defect. DOUGIE: So we don't call the damaged cable satisfactory because the vehicle stayed still. The performance test and component inspection answer different questions. ELEANOR: A component that's excessively worn or corroded is also major. So is an insecure cable, rod or joint. DOUGIE: And we look at movement. A system that's restricted in free movement has a listed major defect. A defective cable guide affecting operation does too. ELEANOR: The words affecting operation matter for that cable-guide defect. The mere existence of a guide doesn't guarantee it's guiding anything. DOUGIE: I've met reception signs with the same problem. The arrow says office and points at a tyre rack. ELEANOR: Your office filing system is predominantly tyres. DOUGIE: They're in size order. Better than the office. ELEANOR: Abnormal lever movement indicating maladjustment or excessive wear is another major defect in this section. We need the finding and its significance, not simply an unfamiliar-looking movement. DOUGIE: Some designs look unusual because they are unusual. We establish how the system works before deciding that the design itself is a fault. ELEANOR: This is where a vague note like handbrake not right becomes unhelpful. What isn't right? The cable, its security, free movement, or the lever movement? DOUGIE: A clear description lets the presenter understand what needs attention. It also stops us hiding several different observations under one broad label. ELEANOR: And a parking brake performance problem belongs under the appropriate performance criteria. It doesn't replace the inspection of the mechanism. DOUGIE: Here's what we do. Follow the cable and associated mechanism through the accessible inspection. Check condition, security and operation. Then test performance using the right method. ELEANOR: Where a component defect applies, record it even if the performance result is satisfactory. Where performance also fails, deal with that finding too. DOUGIE: No swapping one for the other. The cable isn't auditioning for a temporary exemption. ELEANOR: Unlike the owner, who is now on his fifth demonstration.