In the Bay with Dougie and Eleanor, in conversation.

MOTGuard · In the Bay

Condition, size and type

Tyres and suspension · 3 min · With Dougie and Eleanor

Listen to this episode

Download audio · Download transcript · Podcast feed

All 40 episodes — choose another
  1. How this works · 2 min
  2. Fog lamps that do not work · 4 min
  3. The extra passenger · 2 min
  4. Reading the beam · 3 min
  5. Before you blame the car · 3 min
  6. Headlamp aim · 3 min
  7. The LED upgrade · 3 min
  8. One lamp, two jobs · 3 min
  9. Refuse or decline? · 4 min
  10. Stopping a test you started · 3 min
  11. Your licence, your name, your record · 3 min
  12. Not fit to test today · 3 min
  13. The log nobody filled in · 3 min
  14. The man reading the notices · 2 min
  15. When it goes wrong · 3 min
  16. The pads you can't see · 3 min
  17. Pipes and hoses · 3 min
  18. Cables, rods and levers · 3 min
  19. Hydraulics · 3 min
  20. Electric parking brakes and four-wheel drive · 3 min
  21. Which test for which vehicle · 3 min
  22. Tread depth · 3 min
  23. Condition, size and type · 3 min
  24. Play you can feel · 3 min
  25. Compliments to the mechanic · 2 min
  26. Ball joints and dust covers · 3 min
  27. Anti-roll bars · 3 min
  28. Subframes · 3 min
  29. Which test applies · 3 min
  30. The kit car · 3 min
  31. A different engine · 3 min
  32. When the book is blank · 3 min
  33. Smoke testing · 4 min
  34. Before the probe goes in · 3 min
  35. The hybrid with a leaking battery · 3 min
  36. Hand controls and the road test · 3 min
  37. You're done. Now what? · 3 min
  38. The quality-control check, including your own · 3 min
  39. Calibration, checks and the certificates · 4 min
  40. Your risk rating and a site review · 3 min

Transcript

DOUGIE: Two different tyre brands on the front. Owner says they're a matching pair.

ELEANOR: What matches?

DOUGIE: The price. Both were on special offer.

ELEANOR: We need to establish what is actually different. Brand names aren't the size markings.

DOUGIE: Read the sizes and identify the structures. Tyres of different sizes on the same axle are a major defect, subject to the permitted size equivalences in the manual.

ELEANOR: Some tyres have dual size markings. The manual also allows particular standard aspect-ratio combinations. Check those before deciding two markings mean incompatible sizes.

DOUGIE: And radial-ply with cross-ply on the same axle is a major defect. That's different structure.

ELEANOR: Steel and fabric radial-ply tyres count as the same structure.

DOUGIE: Now suppose one's a run-flat and one's conventional.

ELEANOR: The manual permits that combination on the same axle, although it isn't recommended.

DOUGIE: Important distinction. "Not recommended" isn't automatically an MOT rejection. Nor does meeting that one point make it a recommendation.

ELEANOR: They still need to satisfy all the other applicable checks.

DOUGIE: Owner says they've both got plenty of tread. He's brought a photograph.

ELEANOR: What does it show?

DOUGIE: The tread. Very artistic. Nothing of the cut in the sidewall.

ELEANOR: Tread depth doesn't settle tyre condition. Check the tyre itself.

DOUGIE: If ply or cord is visible without touching it, fail. If carefully opening a cut reveals exposed ply or cord, fail irrespective of the cut's size.

ELEANOR: The manual allows a blunt instrument to open a cut without causing further damage. It also sets a separate size criterion where cords can be felt but not seen.

DOUGIE: We use that criterion when it applies. We don't turn "I can feel something" into a guess about cords.

ELEANOR: If you're unsure whether it's cords rather than a foreign object, the manual says pass and advise.

DOUGIE: And assess a lump properly. Normal manufacturing undulations aren't the same as a bulge caused by structural deterioration.

ELEANOR: A lump, bulge or tear caused by separation or partial failure of the structure is a dangerous defect.

DOUGIE: So here's what we do. Read the markings. Apply the size and structure rules. Inspect the actual condition.

ELEANOR: Describe the defect you find. Don't just write "odd tyres".

DOUGIE: That's what the owner called them. Then he asked if turning the wheels straight would help them match.

ELEANOR: One question. A run-flat and a conventional tyre share an axle. Is that combination, by itself, an MOT reason for rejection?

Sources

Source snapshot for this release, published 14/11/2026.

← Back to all episodes